How to Tell if a Tomato is Bad

Tomatoes are a beloved ingredient in dishes around the world, celebrated for their versatility and flavor. However, like all produce, tomatoes have a shelf life, and it’s essential to be able to identify when they’ve gone bad to ensure both the taste and safety of your meals. Here’s a guide to help you distinguish a fresh tomato from a spoiled one.

1. Visual Inspection

a. Discoloration

Fresh tomatoes typically range from bright red to deep red, though some varieties can be orange, yellow, or even purple. Spoiled tomatoes might show:

  • Brown or black patches.
  • Unnatural green spots, especially if the tomato is fully ripe.
  • An overall faded, dull appearance.

b. Mold and Fungus

Rotten moldy tomato on table
A bad tomato that has rotted and has mold on it

Mold can appear as white, green, black, or even blue fuzzy patches on the surface of the tomato or near the stem. If you see any mold, it’s best to discard the tomato immediately.

c. Soft Spots and Bruising

While a ripe tomato should be firm yet yield slightly under pressure, soft spots or sunken areas can indicate rot or over-ripeness. Bruised areas, often darker than the tomato’s regular color, can also be a sign that the tomato is going bad.

2. Touch and Texture

a. Sliminess

A slippery or slimy surface, especially after washing, is a strong indication that a tomato is spoiled.

b. Overly Soft or Mushy

If the tomato feels very soft or mushy all over (not just in one spot), it’s likely past its prime.

c. Wrinkled Skin

Wrinkled tomato
Wrinkled tomato

A tomato that has shriveled or wrinkled skin is dehydrated and likely past its best freshness.

3. Smell

Tomatoes have a distinctive fresh smell. However, a bad tomato might have:

  • An off or sour odor: This indicates that the tomato is starting to ferment or rot.
  • A moldy or musty smell: Mold and bacteria can produce this scent.

4. Taste

While it’s better to avoid tasting a tomato if you’re unsure of its freshness, a spoiled tomato can taste:

  • Bitter or sour: Indicative of over-ripeness or the beginning stages of decay.
  • Off or unusual: Any taste that’s distinctly different from a fresh tomato’s natural sweetness.

5. Safe Storage to Prolong Freshness

To maximize the shelf life of your tomatoes:

  • Room temperature: Store unripe tomatoes at room temperature until they fully ripen.
  • Avoid refrigerating too early: Refrigeration can alter the taste and texture of tomatoes. However, once ripe, you can refrigerate them to slow down the ripening process.
  • Keep dry: Moisture can expedite mold growth. Ensure that your tomatoes are dry if you’re storing them for an extended period.


Being able to determine the freshness of a tomato is a crucial skill for anyone who cooks or enjoys eating them raw. Always trust your senses: if a tomato looks, smells, or feels off, it’s better to err on the side of caution and discard it. Happy tomato tasting!

More things about tomatoes

Sharing is caring!

Bubbly Chef author